One Said To The Other (The OTHER)

[carrymehomestead]

I dug out the One Said single today cos I somehow (re)remembered that the single version (as well as what would you do) is a completely different version than what made it toModern Artillery. And I remembered how upset a whole bunch of people got about the lack of Andy's drum fills in the middle bit.

Those are fucking awesome drum fills!!!!!


....That's it.

[Elyse]

Oh yes i indeed remember the complaints. They gave us all TWO versions and we still bitch.

sad sad sad.

[paulvroc]

hmm...
i don't actually have that version
anybody feeling generous?

[mattheal]

its still available on Itunes, so I dont think anyone is going to share

[Colezy]

I think eBay have the single up for sale fairly regularly.

[BennyD]

yeah i think they should have kept the song it way it was when they did the re-record.

[RTR_Flo]

hmm...
i don't actually have that version
anybody feeling generous?

It's also on the FHOI DVD.

[The Dying Start]

Did they change tempo or something too? I seem to remember Chris saying it wasn't fast enough originally or something. But i was definately one of those who lamented the lack of awesome fills in the re-hash!

[_jimmy_]

I like the structure of the Modern Artillery version but i like the SOUND of the FHOI version.
On FHOI,it sounds much more energetic and raw :D

[paulvroc]

oooh cool
just got it off itunes
yes, theres a tempo change, and the production and recording quality is way, way better
especially the drums...i mean the fills are good, but their actual sound was terrible on the first recording
i prefer the faster tempo

[tanguyen]

wait, so which version did they play on Rove? I'm guessing the single version right?

[_jimmy_]

yep,the single version it is.

[carrymehomestead]

Chris has said himself that he wasn't happy with the production on the MA album, that it "wasn't what he heard in his head", the result of a failed experiment to try and use a hot-shit American producer. I still love MA (in the right mood), but I defnitely think the over-slickness bogs down a lot of otherwise breezy, hooky songs...One Said (single version) being one of the few actual examples we have to listen to, and see of what the album MIGHT have sounded like without...TROMBINO!!! Maybe demos will come out on that mythical TLE box set yeaars later....

[The Dying Start]

Amen to all of that.

[Shadow]

Maybe demos will come out on that mythical TLE box set yeaars later....
Oh god *explosion*... 'Scuse me while I clean up.

[Matt_to_the_End]

Is the single version the one on From Here on In. Where else can you hear it?

[Kacky]

OSTTO ep. Y'know, the CD that includes Blinded as well...

[The Dying Start]

Not to mention Fond Farewell!

[r2jeeves]

Its also on Triple J's hottest 100 vol. 10. Thats probably impossible to come by these days, but thats what I've got it on.

[The Dying Start]

Hey cool, i didn't realise it made it onto the compilation!

[Matt_to_the_End]

Damn, can anyone send me the single version?

Pretty pwease :D

[mattheal]

when someone asked the same question 2 pages ago:

its still available on Itunes, so I dont think anyone is going to share

we arent going to give you something that is commercially available if you really like the band, buy it!

[lozzamouldy]

Theres a really bad copy at belmont library in newcastle if you want to try that :P

[paulvroc]

hahaha
yeh its like $1.70 on iTunes, come on...

[The Dying Start]

Tight-arses, the lot of ya

[Kacky]

Buybuybuy! I'm definitely not a tightass when it comes to TLE. :p

[The Dying Start]

Me either. I'm loosey goosey.

[Ben reed]

thats what HE said

[paulvroc]

hahahahahahahaha
...that is all

[Armistice]

I used my skills to find the version y'all are talking about :ninja:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d4rlNBQlV8g

No thanks are necissary

Also, is it me, or does Chris' voice seem a little on the whiney side? It just seems a little more closed and strained than normal

Anyways, I do like this version. However, I like the album version more

;)

[carrymehomestead]

It is a bit a of a different style for Chris, but man, what a comeback single...I know there are other old school fans that remember when it was the car crash...then Travis leaving??!!...then a nail-biting period of obscurity and anticipation and then BAM!! One Said sounds like a fully regrouped band, its more power pop than anything they did before, but it was right to the fucking point of the living end in...what is it, 2 minutes and change??

(technically What Would You Do? went to radio first, but I don't really count that)

[carrymehomestead]

Plus, Chris' girlfriend looked damn fine in the video.

[The Dying Start]

She is quite the catch, yes.